What the Court looks at when dealing with a parent's history of drug and alcohol usage
When a parent has a history of drug or alcohol use, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia does not automatically decide that the parent is unsafe or that they should have little or no time with their children.
Instead, the Court looks at the actual risk to the children.
Recent decisions of Division 1 judges show that the Court takes a practical and fact-based approach.
Past drug or alcohol use does not automatically mean that a parent presents an unacceptable risk. The important question is what has happened since, and what is likely to happen in the future.
The Court's Approach to Risk: What the Recent Cases Tell Us
The Court's approach to risk is explained in Isles & Nelissen.¹
The Court generally asks:
What could happen to the child?
How likely is it to happen?
How serious would the harm be if it happened?
Can the risk be reduced by putting safeguards in place?
Drug and alcohol use is considered through this framework.
Past drug use does not automatically mean no time
A parent's history of drug use is only part of the picture.
The Court will also consider evidence about the parent's current circumstances, including whether they have stopped using drugs, undertaken treatment, complied with testing and demonstrated that they can safely care for their children.
For example, in Arteta & Julini, the father's admitted illicit drug use was considered alongside a lengthy period of clear drug testing and other evidence about his circumstances.²
The case is a useful reminder that the Court looks at the evidence of what is happening now, not simply what happened in the past.
If you act for the parent who has used drugs or alcohol - be honest
Honesty is extremely important.
If a parent tries to hide or minimise their drug or alcohol use, this can damage their credibility.
The Court is more likely to have confidence in a parent who:
accepts what happened;
understands why it was a problem;
gets appropriate help;
follows treatment advice; and
can show that their behaviour has changed.
In simple terms, the Court needs to be able to trust the parent.
Drug and alcohol testing matters
Testing can provide objective evidence about what is happening now.
It can help show:
whether the parent is staying drug-free;
whether the parent is complying with Court orders;
whether the parent's evidence is consistent with the test results; and
whether the risk has reduced over time.
Recent testing is generally more useful than old testing.
In Rahal & Rahal (No 5), the Court allowed the father significant weekday, weekend and holiday time with the children while also imposing a drug-testing regime and related restraints.³
This is an example of the Court using testing and conditions to manage risk rather than simply stopping a parent's time with their children.
Show the Court that things have changed
If drug or alcohol use was a problem in the past, evidence showing that the situation is now different can be very important.
This might include:
clean drug tests;
reports from supervised contact visits;
stable employment;
stable accommodation;
counselling or treatment reports;
psychological reports; and
compliance with previous Court orders.
The more consistent the evidence, the easier it is for the Court to see that the change is genuine.
Sometimes time can help
If a parent has only recently stopped using drugs or started treatment, there may not yet be enough evidence to show long-term change.
In some cases, having more time to build a history of clean testing and compliance can make a significant difference.
That needs to be balanced against the need to protect the children while that evidence is being built.
If you act for the other parent
Drug or alcohol use should usually be connected to the bigger picture.
For example, the concern may be greater where substance use is also connected with:
family violence;
mental health problems;
poor judgment;
lack of insight;
dishonesty;
instability;
criminal behaviour; or
failure to follow previous Court orders.
The argument should not simply be:
“They use drugs, so the children are unsafe.”
Instead, the evidence should explain what the actual risk is and why it is likely to happen.
The risk is not always just about being intoxicated
The decision in Morvand & Sleeman is a useful example.
The case involved concerns about the father's alcohol and illicit drug use. The Court ultimately ordered a period of supervised time with the children by the paternal grandmother.⁴
The concern about illegal drug use can also go beyond whether a parent is affected by drugs while looking after the children.
There can be risks associated with obtaining illegal drugs, having drugs in the home and possible police involvement.
So saying:
“I never use drugs when the children are with me”, may not completely answer the concern.
Lack of insight can make the situation worse
A very different outcome occurred in Armonas & Armonas.
The father had a long history of illicit substance abuse and misuse of prescription medication. He had also experienced drug-induced psychoses and hospitalisations.
The Court was concerned about his lack of transparency and his failure to properly engage with treating professionals.
The Court found that he presented an unacceptable risk of harm to the child and that the risk could not be adequately managed through safeguards. The child was ordered to spend no time with the father.⁵
This case demonstrates why drug use should not be looked at in isolation.
The Court was concerned not only about substance use, but also about the father's mental health, insight, honesty and engagement with treatment.
What orders can the Court make?
There is no single outcome for cases involving drug or alcohol use.
Depending on the level of risk, the Court may order:
No time
In serious cases, the Court may decide that the children should not spend time with the parent.
Armonas & Armonas is an example where the Court found that the risk could not be safely managed.⁵
Supervised time
The children may spend time with the parent while another suitable adult or professional supervises the visits.
Morvand & Sleeman is an example of supervision being used to manage concerns about substance use.⁴
Gradually increasing time
The Court may start with limited time and increase it if the parent demonstrates that they can safely care for the children.
Drug and alcohol testing
The Court may require regular testing.
The results can then be linked to changes in parenting arrangements.
Rahal & Rahal (No 5) demonstrates how a testing regime can operate alongside significant parenting time.³
Rules about drugs and alcohol
Orders can include rules about:
using illegal drugs;
drinking alcohol before or during time with the children;
taking medication that has not been prescribed;
taking prescribed medication incorrectly; and
driving with the children after drinking or using drugs.
Treatment and counselling
The Court may also require a parent to participate in drug and alcohol counselling, parenting programs or other appropriate support.
Another example: testing before parenting time
In Bartalotti & Bartalotti, the Court ordered the father to spend time with the child on Saturdays, subject to drug testing and a clean test before that time commenced.⁶
Again, the outcome was not simply “drug use equals no contact”.
Instead, the Court used conditions to manage the identified risk.
The main lesson
The Court does not simply ask:
“Has this parent used drugs or alcohol?”
It asks:
“What risk does the substance use create for these children, how likely is that risk, how serious could the consequences be, and can the risk be managed?”
For the parent who has used drugs or alcohol, the strongest approach is usually:
Honesty + treatment + testing + proof of change.
For the other parent, the focus should be:
The actual risk + the evidence + why the proposed safeguards may not be enough.
Ultimately, past drug or alcohol use is not necessarily the end of the relationship between a parent and child. What matters is the evidence about the parent's behaviour now, the risk to the children and what can safely happen next.
This information is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. Every parenting case depends on its particular facts and evidence. For advice specific to your circumstances, contact us to arrange a consultation with our family lawyer.
Footnotes
1. Isles & Nelissen (2022) FLC 94-092; [2022] FedCFamC1A 97. (Astergren CJ, McClelland, Aldridge, Austin and Tree JJ, 1 July 2022) The Full Court's decision sets out the approach to assessing unacceptable risk in parenting proceedings.
2. Arteta & Julini [2024] FedCFamC1F 98. (Tree J, 28 February 2024) The case concerned admitted illicit drug use and subsequent evidence including clear drug testing.
3. Rahal & Rahal (No 5) [2025] FedCFamC1F 141 (Altobelli J, 6 March 2025). The Court ordered significant parenting time together with a drug-testing regime and related restraints.
4. Morvand & Sleeman [2024] FedCFamC1F 894 (Curran J, 19 December 2024). The case concerned safety issues arising from the father's alcohol and drug use, with supervised time ordered for a period.
5. Armonas & Armonas [2025] FedCFamC1F 220 (Williams J, 4 April 2025). The Court found an unacceptable risk of harm that could not be adequately managed by safeguards and ordered that the child spend no time with the father.
6. Bartalotti & Bartalotti [2025] FedCFamC1F 212 (McGuire J, 15 April 2025). The Court ordered Saturday time with the child subject to the father undertaking drug testing and producing clean results before the time commenced.
